P.O. Box 909 ● Trenton, NJ 08605-0909 ● Phone: 609.695.7600 ● Fax: 609.695.0413 ● Web: www.njsba.org/PI

Voters to Decide School-Funding Questions on April 15

  • Voters in 549 districts to decide school district “base” budgets
  • 28 districts propose one or more additional budget questions—the fewest ever requested
  • 15 districts have bond referendums for construction projects

TRENTON, April 4, 2008—A new law that requires an unprecedented 60-percent majority of voters to approve additional school-funding questions, or “second ballot questions,” appears to be having a chilling effect on the number of such questions put before voters in this year’s Annual School Election, the New Jersey School Boards Association reported today.

In all, 28 school districts are proposing 33 additional ballot questions in the April 15 school election—the lowest number since the current system of second ballot questions was established a dozen years ago. It is a sharp decrease from last year, when 65 school districts proposed a total of 87 additional spending questions.

When a school board proposes a second ballot question, it is asking voters to approve expenditures above the permissible increase (state-imposed tax-levy cap) in school property taxes reflected in the main budget question (or “base budget” proposal).  School boards may present voters with one or more additional ballot questions, which must specify the program or positions to be funded.

The 33 additional questions on the April 15 ballot in 28 school districts represent a dramatic downturn from the previous eight years, when an average of 70 school boards proposed a total of 86 second ballot questions each year.

Base budgets and second questions During the Annual School Election, voters in 549 school districts will act on proposed base budgets covering school district operating costs for 2008-2009. An April 2007 state law placed a 4-percent cap on local school property tax levy increases in base budgets; The same law requires a 60-percent supermajority of voters to approve school districts’ second ballot proposals to exceed that levy cap.

“No other public question in New Jersey requires a super-majority vote—not even Constitutional amendments,” said Kevin E. Ciak, NJSBA president.  “Under this law, a minority of voters—41 percent—can outweigh the will of the majority.  The requirement could stand in the way of communities’ ability to raise their own funds for needed school programs.”

For 2008, many of the second ballot questions address educational programs and services.

  • 20 of the 38 questions ask voters to approve funding for staff. Eight specify classroom teachers or aides; two ask for art/music teachers; and two seek counselors.
  • 11 questions focus on safety equipment or security staff.
  • Five questions ask voters to approve full-day kindergarten.

Other questions  The Annual School Election also serves as one of five dates during the year when school boards can place construction proposals on the ballot. On April 15, voters in 15 districts will act on a total of $136 million in proposed school construction.

School districts may also proposed organizational changes to voters during the Annual School Election.  Two districts will ask voters to change the number of members on their local school board: Frenchtown in Hunterdon County from nine to seven members, and Plumsted Township in Ocean County from five to seven members.

Rejected budget and second-ballot questions If voters reject the base budget, the proposal is sent to the municipal governing body for review. The municipality may leave the budget intact, or make cuts.  Current law provides a process for a school board to appeal to the commissioner of education if a municipality’s cuts to a defeated base budget would prevent the school district from providing an adequate education or if it would undermine the district’s financial stability.

However, if voters reject a second ballot questions, the issue does not go to the municipal governing body for review and there is no appeal; the voters’ word is final. Unless there is a gift or outside funding, the specific program or staffing in the second question is lost for the year and the school board cannot transfer budget funds to sustain the program or service. 

Summary of Additional Ballot Finance Questions (“Second Ballot Questions”)

Voters in 28 school districts will act on 33 second ballot questions asking for spending that would exceed to the state-imposed 4-percent cap on the tax levy. (See list of districts at the end of this release.)

Staffing:

            Classroom teachers or aides: 8 questions

            Counseling (guidance, social workers, etc.): 2 questions

            Arts/music teachers: 2 questions

            Security guards/school resource officers: 2 questions

            Other staff (nurses, cafeteria staff, librarians, etc.): 6 questions

Programs and services:

            Instructional programs (enrichment programs, summer school, basic skills, etc.): 4 questions

            Athletic programs: 4 questions

            Busing: 2 questions

            Computers and technology equipment: 5 questions

            Full-day kindergarten or pre-school: 5 questions

            Extracurricular activities (clubs, after-school programs, etc.): 3 questions

Facilities/equipment:

Renovations (roofs, windows, boilers, athletic fields, playgrounds): 8 questions

            Security (includes cameras, fire safety equipment, etc.): 9 questions

(Note: The numbers add up to more than the total number of questions, 33, because many second-ballot questions address more than one expenditure area.)

Source: New Jersey School Boards Association

Annual School Election

April 15, 2008

BALLOT PROPOSALS

  • Base budgets: 549 school districts
  • Additional finance questions (“second ballot questions”): 33 questions in 28 districts

Number of additional ballot questions, 1997-2008:

2008: 33

2007: 87

2006: 72

2005: 73

2004: 75

2003: 89

2002:    99

2001:    91

2000:  100

1999:    92

1998:  104

1997:  176

 

 

 

 

 

 

·         Other ballot proposals (not related to school operating budget)

o        Construction bond referendums: 15 districts 

o        Change in board composition: 2 districts to change the number of members

o        Recall: 1 district (Recall of a member of the Hardyston Board of Education, Sussex County)

New Jersey School Districts With Additional Budget Questions on the April 15 Ballot

28 districts with 33 questions

Note: The list below only includes districts where school boards proposed additional budget questions asking voters to decide proposed expenditures above the state-imposed tax-levy cap on the base budget. The list does not include bond referendums for construction projects or non-budget questions such as asking voters to change the number of members on the school board.

Bergen County

Cresskill

Fair Lawn

Hasbrouck Heights (2 questions)

Hillsdale

Lyndhurst

Park Ridge

Ramsey

River Vale

Saddle Brook

Westwood Regional

 

Camden County

Somerdale

Winslow Township

 

Essex County

Bloomfield

North Caldwell

 

Gloucester County

East Greenwich Township

Washington Township

 

Monmouth County

Millstone Township

Wall Township

 

Morris County

Boonton Town (4 questions)

District of the Chathams

Mount Olive

 

Ocean County

Berkeley Township

Brick Township (2 questions)

Jackson Township

Lacey Township

 

Passaic County

Hawthorne

Sussex County

Hardyston Township

 

Warren County

Great Meadows Regional

********

The New Jersey School Boards Association, a federation of district boards of education, advocates the interests of school districts, trains local school board members, and provides resources for the advancement of public education.

###