Frustrated by state government’s longtime failure to address pension and health benefit costs, many school board members came to the Nov. 17 NJSBA Delegate Assembly to question officials who have proposed comprehensive but controversial reforms.
“We had a healthy exchange of views, and I am pleased that our delegates took the opportunity to directly engage policy leaders on these critical issues,” said Dr. Lawrence S. Feinsod, NJSBA executive director. “While the NJSBA recognizes that reforms are urgently needed, we also understand that fundamental changes can only be successful if they are supported by the local school boards who will be asked to implement them.”
The audience at the Mercer County Community College conference center in West Windsor included 177 school board members and guests. Former New Jersey Education Commissioner Lucille Davy and Mark Magyar, associate executive director for policy development in the Senate Democratic Majority Office, fielded a steady stream of questions from school board delegates concerning recommendations in the 38-page Path to Progess report released this summer by the Legislature’s Economic and Fiscal Policy Workgroup.
Among the key recommendations in the report:
- Shift new state and local government employees, and those with less than five years of service, out of the current pension system. Place them in a “sustainable hybrid system” that combines some level of benefit from the current system with a 401K plan similar to retirement plans offered by private companies.
- Preserve the current pension system for employees with over five years of service.
- Shift all state and local government employees’ and retirees’ health care coverage from Platinum to Gold levels of coverage.
- Require all new state and local government retirees to pay the same percentage of premium costs they paid when working.
- Merge all K-4, K-5, K-6, K-8, and K-9 school districts into K-12 regional districts to improve the quality of education and promote efficiency.
- Permit the establishment of two county-wide school district pilot programs.
- Move toward full state funding and administration of “extraordinary special education.”
- Establish a state-level group to address students for whom an Individual Evaluation Placement (IEP) team is considering a residential program.
In response to a question from the audience, Magyar said creation of the countywide pilot districts would be voluntary and that legislation to move that recommendation forward would be introduced shortly.
Significant statutory roadblocks to regionalization exist, Magyar said.
For example, when a smaller district regionalizes, it is required to adopt the salary guide of the larger district, which usually creates greater employment costs and has been an immediate cost for the smaller district and an expensive impediment to moving forward with a merger. That issue, among others, remains unresolved, as described in Impediments to Regionalization, an NJSBA study provided to the governor’s office on Feb. 16, 2018.
Magyar stressed that the “Path to Progress” report was under discussion and that no legislation has been introduced to implement its recommendations.
Davy emphasized that the regionalization recommendations would improve the delivery of education, helping smaller districts have access to greater resources to help students. Bigger districts can hire more teachers with specialized skills than smaller districts, she said.
In a discussion moderated by NJSBA President Dan Sinclair, school board members asked how the report’s proposals would affect them.
George Babula, of the Harmony Township school board in Warren County, asked if the reforms would be approved “without input from the governor’s office.” Magyar responded that “this only gets done if it has broad public support.”
Henry Goldsmith of the Weymouth Township school board in Atlantic County asked how regionalization would affect his 165-student Pre-K-8 district. Davy and Magyar said their intention is not to close schools or transfer students to other schools.
Clara Williams of the Teaneck Board of Education in Bergen County asked if the legislative work group would study how charter schools are affecting school funding.
“I implore you to consider the impact of charter schools on this entire funding situation,” Williams said.
Jean Trujillo of the Hillsborough Township school board in Somerset County noted that her schools had been categorized as “underfunded” for years. But when new budget figures were released, her district was listed as $5.6 million “overfunded.” To cover unexpected budget gaps, she asked if the state would consider allowing towns to increase taxes above 2 percent without asking permission from voters in a referendum, as current law requires.
Magyar said that is “something we should look at,” and offered to discuss the district’s situation in further detail.
The conversation about reforms and solutions, Magyar told the audience, should be continued. He encouraged board members to contact him at [email protected]
NJSBA plans to post a video of the program on its website.