At its meeting on Oct. 27, 2026, the School Ethics Commission took the following action: discussed one matter in accordance with the SEC’s previous regulations; discussed nine matters in accordance with the SEC’s new/amended regulations; considered adopting 12 decisions; and considered four new advisory opinion requests.

Of the 12 decisions considered for adoption, nine were posted on the Department of Education’s website; therefore, the remaining three matters – C41-26, C42-26, and C44-26 – remain pending. The SEC did not post any new public advisory opinions.  

This article will review the five decisions that the SEC dismissed as untimely pursuant to N.J.A.C. 6A:28-6.5, and next week’s article will analyze the four matters that the SEC dismissed for lack of probable cause.

  1. Dismissals (Untimely Matters)
  1. C48-26, C49-26, C50-26, and C61-26

Complainant, a former employee in the district, filed four (4) ethics complaints, each against a separate administrator, but based upon substantially the same facts, and all stemming from the allegation that the “the district conducted only a minimal and incomplete investigation” of complainant’s report that one of the district’s security guards made a false complaint about him on September 16, 2024. 

With respect to the investigation, complainant specifically argued that respondents violated N.J.S.A. 18A:12-24(b), (e), (f), and (i) in connection with the following conduct: C48-26 – respondent, a building principal, did not interview complainant and relied solely upon the security guard’s statement; C49-26 – respondent, the superintendent, “escalated the situation” by sending out an email with complainant’s photograph that implied that he was not permitted on school property; C50-26 – respondent, the Director of Human Resources, oversaw the investigation, and did not facilitate the discussion of complainant’s allegations during public session at a board meeting as complainant had requested; and C61-26 – respondent, the  Director of Administration, met with complainant but turned off the recorder during the interview, did not document complainant’s statements, and refused to view the video related to the incident.

In their written statements, all respondents sought the dismissal of the complaints because complainant filed the complaints beyond the 180-day limitation period.  According to complainant, he did not file his complaints until 2026 because he “did not know, and could not have reasonably known, that the [SEC] had jurisdiction until late 2025.”  He further explained that, it was not until he discussed the situation with a “friend” that he was “informed” that he was able to pursue his claims through the SEC.  

The SEC dismissed all four complaints as untimely pursuant to N.J.A.C. 6A:28-6.5.  The SEC concluded that “[c]omplainant was aware of the events that formed the … [c]omplaint[s] when they were happening,” and noted that complainant “could have researched potential filing procedures…including whether filing an ethics complaint was an option.”  The SEC emphasized that complainant’s “ignorance of the administrative process does not allow him to file a complaint two years later,” and further determined that there were no extraordinary circumstances present to warrant relaxation of the 180-days limitation period. 

In addition to the complaints being untimely, the SEC also noted that it does not have jurisdiction over matters regarding potential violations of board policies and/or human resources policies, including whether the district conducted a proper investigation.

  • C39-26

In C39-26, complainant, the business administrator, alleged that respondent, the superintendent, violated N.J.S.A. 18A:12-24(c) and (e) because he used the board’s Amazon account for personal purchases, and his “403(b) employer match was overpaid” in 2020, 2021, and 2022.  According to complainant, respondent also violated N.J.S.A. 18A:12-24(c) and (d) because he supervised his spouse, the principal, and his child was hired without approval from the Executive County Superintendent. Complainant acknowledged that some of her claims “fall outside the 180-day requirement,” but argued that they are part of a “longstanding and ongoing pattern of behavior within the school,” and also cited her fear of retaliation as a reason for the delay. 

Because the alleged conduct occurred from 2008 through July 2025, and complainant “was aware of the events that formed the basis of the present [c]omplaint when they were happening,” the SEC dismissed the complaint for untimeliness pursuant to N.J.A.C. 6A:28-6.5.  The SEC also concluded that there were no extraordinary circumstances to compel relaxation of the 180-days limitation period.  Although the complaint was untimely, the SEC did not find it to be frivolous, and denied the request for sanctions.   

  • Next Week’s Article

Next week’s article will analyze the remaining four matters dismissed by the SEC for lack of probable cause.  

As a reminder, school officials who would like to request an advisory opinion regarding their own or another school official’s prospective conduct may do so through the SEC.

For further information about these matters, please contact the NJSBA Legal Department at (609) 278-5279, or your board attorney for specific legal advice.